Today’s colleges and universities face big challenges as they strive to be better. They have to deal with fewer students, money problems, and teaching interruptions. These issues are making them really think about what matters1. But, this tough time is also a chance for bold leaders to make school better for everyone.
A recent survey by BCG found that 72% of college leaders worry that people are losing faith in higher education1. This is a big wake-up call, showing how critical it is to work together and come up with strong plans. By keeping an eye on what’s new, like closer work between schools and companies and what students want, schools can set themselves up for success.
BCG is here to help educational leaders lead through change. We really get the current landscape, helping schools spot new chances to grow strong. With our support, your school can do well even in tough times2.
Key Takeaways:
- Embrace a holistic approach to academic excellence that aligns with the changing needs of students, employers, and the broader community.
- Leverage data-driven insights to inform strategic decision-making, drive innovation, and enhance the overall student experience.
- Cultivate a culture of collaboration and interdisciplinary learning to prepare students for the complex challenges of the 21st century.
- Invest in faculty expertise, cutting-edge research, and innovative teaching methodologies to position your institution as a global leader.
- Prioritize diversity, inclusion, and community engagement to create a transformative campus environment that fosters personal and professional growth.
Defining Higher Education Excellence
Finding academic excellence in higher education is complex. It involves many linked factors. These include aiming for academic quality. Schools work hard to offer life-changing learning opportunities, support significant research, and build a lively campus culture3.
Key Components of Academic Quality
How we see academic quality in higher education is more than test scores and graduation rates. We look at everything that affects learning. This includes the students’ experiences before college, how they study, their activities, and the school’s environment3.
Metrics for Measuring Institutional Performance
Judging how well colleges are doing needs a wide approach. This approach should cover many different areas. We should check on the grades, how well off students become, their happiness, and their thinking and people skills. We also look at if they help their community and how good they are at solving real-life problems3.
| Metric | Description |
|---|---|
| Grades | Evaluating academic achievement and learning outcomes |
| Economic Benefits | Measuring the financial and career-related advantages for students |
| Quality of Life | Assessing the overall well-being and personal development of students |
| Cognitive Complexity | Gauging the depth and breadth of intellectual and critical thinking skills |
| Knowledge Acquisition | Evaluating the expansion of disciplinary and interdisciplinary knowledge |
| Humanitarianism | Measuring the development of ethical, altruistic, and civic-minded attitudes |
| Interpersonal and Intrapersonal Competence | Assessing the growth of social, emotional, and self-awareness skills |
| Practical Competence | Evaluating the acquisition of applied, problem-solving, and life skills |
Looking at a broad spectrum of metrics helps schools understand their institutional performance. It also guides them in supporting their students’ overall growth3.
“The pursuit of higher education excellence is not a one-size-fits-all approach. It requires a thoughtful and contextualized understanding of the unique strengths, challenges, and aspirations of each institution.”
Academic excellence is changing with the times in higher education. It must meet the new needs of students, workplaces, and society. Getting a broad view of academic quality and institutional performance is key. It helps schools provide truly impactful education453.
Student Success: The Cornerstone of Excellence
Student success is the key to excellent higher education. Top institutions focus on helping students do well. They make sure students learn a lot and feel supported6. These places aim for students to love learning, feel at home on campus, and grow as well-rounded individuals.
Engaging Learning Experiences
Great schools create exciting ways for students to learn. They spark a love for learning and prepare students for success7. They do this by getting students involved and working together with their teachers. This approach helps students reach their full potential.
Supportive Campus Environment
A caring campus is crucial for success6. Many students face mental health challenges while at college. Good schools help by offering support like counseling and wellness programs6. They also provide strong academic guidance. This support network helps students do well in their studies and life6.
Mental health support leads to better grades and happier students6. This shows how important a supportive environment is.
8 Fisk University is a great example. It has been a top school since 1866. It has small classes, high performance, and strong student support8.
Fisk University is known for helping students succeed. It shows the impact of a caring campus.
6 Students do better when they feel they belong at their school6. Creating a friendly, supportive culture is crucial for success. It helps students do their best, in and out of class.
“Higher education is about changing lives. When we inspire and support our students, they achieve amazing things. This leads to their long-term success.”
Higher Education Excellence: Challenges and Opportunities
The shape of higher education in the U.S. is changing due to COVID-19. This has caused big changes, like fewer students and questions about college’s worth9. The Excellence in Higher Education (EHE) Guide helps colleges deal with these issues by combining the Baldrige model with higher education rules9.
COVID-19 made problems in higher education worse. Student debt, expensive tuition, and segregation issues grew10. Many students, especially those of color, find it hard to graduate on time. They also found it challenging to study remotely during the pandemic.
Still, these hard times can lead to good changes. Colleges can find new ways to help students succeed10. Some schools that did well with supporting students shared their methods at the Raise the Bar summit in August 202210.
Colleges are using technology to keep more students and help them graduate quickly11. This includes giving students good advice and hands-on learning experiences11. Schools like Arizona State and Georgia State show how digital tools can boost student success11.
By tackling current issues and taking on new chances, colleges can truly transform education. The EHE method supports colleges that aim for top performance and fairness in education.
| Metric | National Average | Leading Institutions |
|---|---|---|
| 6-year graduation rate for first-time students | 60%10 | Higher completion rates for students facing challenges10 |
| 6-year graduation rate for underrepresented students of color | Less than 50%10 | Demonstrated higher completion rates10 |
| Time to degree completion | 4 years for most majors11 | Strong academic pathways, robust advising, and high-impact practices to improve graduation rates and reduce time to degree11 |
“We must take bold action to address the pressing challenges facing higher education and seize the opportunities to transform the student experience and advance equity. By leveraging the power of data, technology, and innovative practices, we can reimagine the future of higher education and ensure that all students have the chance to reach their full potential.”
Faculty Expertise: Driving Innovation and Impact
The success of any academic institution largely depends on its faculty. They’re known for their groundbreaking research and new teaching methods. These experts at top universities lead the way in higher education12.
Cutting-Edge Research and Scholarship
At places that value innovation, faculty are free to explore. They get to work on studies that change what we know. This support leads to amazing discoveries and top-notch education12.
Innovative Teaching Methodologies
Besides research, these universities are famous for their teaching. They use design thinking and tech to make learning better for students. This helps students prepare for future jobs12.
The mix of expert faculty, new research, and fresh teaching styles sets a bar for schools. It makes them stand out as places of learning and discovery13.
| Key Factors for Fostering Innovation in Academia |
|---|
|
Though facing many hurdles, academia thrives with its innovative faculty13. A focus on systems and innovation culture inspires impactful research. It also enhances teaching13.
“The fusion of faculty expertise, cutting-edge research, and innovative teaching methodologies is a hallmark of higher education excellence.”
Changes in higher learning showcase faculty’s key role14. Building a supportive innovation ecosystem can make extraordinary education possible. This approach helps schools shine as learning hubs12.
Cultivating a Global Reputation
When it comes to being the best in higher education, a global reputation is key. Achieving this means teaming up with others worldwide and pulling in the best minds from around the globe.
Being at the forefront with fresh research, exciting course offers, and a place where everyone feels welcome are big steps towards this goal.
International Collaborations and Partnerships
Working with others from different countries is vital for any college or university. It allows the sharing of new ideas and the chance to go beyond borders with research. This also makes moving between schools easier for both teachers and students.
Through wide-reaching academic teamwork, schools can be seen more and have a bigger influence globally.
Attracting Top Talent Worldwide
Getting the best teachers and researchers from everywhere is a sign of a great school. Leading institutions offer a space where anyone, from the newest to the most experienced, can really shine. This creates a culture where growth and new ideas flourish.
By forming strong bonds with others across the globe and inviting top talents, universities can be leaders in education. They become centers of excellence that leave a mark worldwide.
“A supportive environment for growth, reinvention, and revitalization is crucial for all faculty members’ career phases.”
Higher Education Excellence
Excellence in higher education is a key goal. It requires careful planning and big changes. The Association of American Colleges and Universities (AAC&U) leads this effort. They provide a plan for colleges and universities. This helps them aim for top-notch education15.
At the center of AAC&U’s work is a focus on big changes within schools. They help schools adapt and grow. This means helping campuses create initiatives for fairness, new ideas, and top education standards15.
- The plan includes 89 different universities and colleges15. It covers 21 colleges in California’s university system15.
- It also includes famous Ivy League schools like Columbia, Princeton, and more15.
- Plus, it recognizes the work of 6 Texas-based universities15. Also, 3 top law schools received acknowledgment15.
- 16 Ohio-based universities are part of the plan as well15.
The AAC&U’s plan is based on the Excellence in Higher Education (EHE) model. This model is made for colleges and universities. It looks at leadership, goals, services, and more16.
The EHE model is used by about 50 groups at Rutgers University16. It has been influenced by top experts in education. These experts have helped develop the model16.
They know higher education faces big challenges. Economic and policy changes are happening fast. The EHE model offers a way forward. It helps colleges and universities become better for the future16.
Higher education excellence is not just in classrooms. Look at the Pearson Faculty Awards. This program celebrates great teachers. It honors their work in helping students and their communities17.
Applying for the Pearson Faculty Awards means wanting a better tomorrow for higher education. It celebrates teaching that shapes the future of colleges and universities17. The program recognizes how teachers impact students and their societies17.
“The Pearson Faculty Awards program represents a commitment to excellence in higher education, recognizing the innovative teaching methods, inclusive practices, and transformative leadership that are shaping the future of our colleges and universities.”
Universities strive for excellence with AAC&U’s plan. The Pearson Faculty Awards are part of this too. These efforts show a shared goal. It’s about making education better and more impactful151617.
Fostering Career Readiness and Lifelong Learning
In higher education, it’s not just about learning facts. It’s about how to excel in the future. Universities work to get students ready for jobs and to keep learning for life. This way, graduates can do well in changing job markets18.
Industry-Academic Partnerships
Getting companies and schools to work together is key. They make sure what students learn matches what jobs need. By creating projects, internships, and advice programs, students learn from real challenges. This connection between school and work is a big help19.
Developing Transferable Skills
Schools focus not only on what’s in the books but also on skills everyone can use. Learning how to think critically, solve problems, and communicate well is crucial. These skills are what employers look for and help students fit into many jobs20. With these skills, graduates are ready to learn throughout their careers and adapt to new work challenges18.
The job world keeps changing, and education needs to keep up. To prepare students for their careers, universities are working closely with companies. They aim to develop skills that will serve students in any job, now and in the future20.
Diversity and Inclusion: A Catalyst for Excellence
In higher education, a strong focus on diversity and inclusion is key to success. The American Association of Colleges and Universities (AAC&U) sees diversity as essential for student and institution success21. Their plan encourages learning for all, supporting faculty in creating inclusive environments, and embracing the diversity among students21.
The Ford Foundation’s initiative, Making Excellence Inclusive, is helping schools take big steps toward including diverse perspectives21. It includes studies aimed at showing how to make campuses more welcoming and how to blend diversity with quality seamlessly21. These studies address issues like the lower success rates of certain groups, such as African American and Latino/a students, offering ways to close these achievement gaps21.
Institutions must think hard about how their usual ways of teaching and interacting affect certain marginalized groups21. The AAC&U’s model for Inclusive Excellence stresses the need to use diversity to improve how students learn and develop21.
“Diversity must be implemented intentionally to yield educational benefits.”21
Studies clearly show the benefits of diverse learning environments22. These include exposure to new ideas, improved problem-solving, and better cultural understanding22. Schools must actively avoid practices that harm these students and instead, work towards equal outcomes for all22.
The “Diversity Scorecard,” developed by Bauman et al., offers a way for schools to monitor and improve on racial disparities22. Some schools, like Loyola Marymount University, have used this tool to find and fill gaps in student success22.
Improving diversity and inclusion is a detailed process22. It needs to be understood deeply, with effort that goes far beyond just putting policies in place22.
The University of California, Berkeley, sets a great example of how to make real change towards inclusive excellence23. Since the late 1800s, they’ve led in making education accessible to all kinds of people. Now, their efforts continue through various programs supporting diversity and inclusion23.
Berkeley has moved from just reacting to issues to proactively using diversity23. Their strategic approach has boosted their educational quality and campus environment23.
In striving for excellence, education institutions should hold firm to their commitment to diversity and inclusion. By empowering everyone, be it students or faculty, and by creating a welcoming culture, these institutions tap into the power of diversity and push themselves towards the top in education and success for all.
The Campus Experience: Beyond Academics
Top universities care about more than just classes. They offer a journey of growth24. This approach, centered on SEL and a “whole child” view, makes successful individuals24.
Residential Life and Student Organizations
Campus life is key to college. Most students join clubs or do other activities outside of class25. Doing this can help get better jobs after graduation25. Plus, meeting people in college can lead to many job chances25.
Clubs, events, and volunteering build skills and a sense of belonging. Nearly all students go to school events, which boosts their learning and growth25.
Wellness and Personal Development
Good universities focus on student health and growth. Personal growth in college is big – 40% of it, more than grades25. Exercise, a good diet, and rest can improve grades by 30%25.
By caring for students’ well-being, schools create strong learners24. They aim for total student growth, not just grades, empowering them for life24.
The best universities provide lots of ways for students to grow. They mix classes with activities, promoting health and growth2425.
Interdisciplinary Learning: Bridging Boundaries
Today’s world changes fast. So, we need new ways to solve big issues. Interdisciplinary learning mixes different fields to find fresh, creative answers26.
Collaborative Research and Teaching
Interdisciplinary learning means working together in studies and teaching, no matter the subject. In 2019, experts from 32 areas picked top educators for a special project26. They made a guide, “Ambitious Learning for an Increasingly Complex World,” to help others lead effective programs. This guide came out in 2020, during COVID-1926.
The guide talks about the importance of working together and deep study in interdisciplinary learning. It says teachers and students need more training26. The guide also suggests changes to schools. It aims to make research online and outdoor learning easier. Plus, it suggests more projects that aren’t just about IDL26.
Preparing Students for Complex Challenges
Interdisciplinary learning teaches students how to solve tough, real-world problems. The 2020 guide shows how schools can work with experts for the best results26. This way, students see things from many angles and learn important thinking and communication skills.
Research from 2007 also highlights interdisciplinary learning’s value27. It talks about using different subjects to solve big issues, like in archaeology. It shows that the process and method are what’s key for success, not just the subjects27.
As the world gets more complex, schools must teach in new ways. Interdisciplinary learning is vital for students today. It helps them gain the skills to succeed in a changing world28.
“Interdisciplinary learning empowers students to bridge disciplines and collaborate in ways that foster innovative solutions to complex challenges.”
| Characteristic | Multidisciplinary | Interdisciplinary | Bridging Disciplines |
|---|---|---|---|
| Approach | Separate and distinct disciplines | Integration of multiple disciplines | Synthesis of knowledge across disciplines |
| Goal | Acquire knowledge and skills within individual disciplines | Solve complex problems by combining insights from different disciplines | Develop new frameworks and methodologies that transcend traditional academic boundaries |
| Collaboration | Limited interaction between disciplines | Active collaboration and exchange of ideas between disciplines | Deeply integrated, iterative collaboration that reshapes disciplinary boundaries |
Investing in Higher Education Excellence
Reaching the peak of education excellence involves wise investment. Schools need to plan their spending and where they put resources. This helps them get better, help students more, and lead in the world of higher education.
Funding Strategies and Resource Allocation
Getting enough money is key for schools to shine. They use this cash to offer great classes, keep amazing teachers, and build cool facilities. Searching for funds in different places like grants, donations, and revenue ideas is crucial. The U.S. Department of Education helps by pushing for great teaching, tutoring, and more access to useful subjects and activities.
Allocating resources well is just as vital. This means spending money where it really helps students and teachers improve, and the school grows. They aim to solve issues like teacher shortages, student stress, and better learning conditions29. By sticking to their main goals, colleges can make the most of what they have and create a top-notch education environment.
Building a Culture of Continuous Improvement
To keep up with what students and the job market need, schools must always try to get better. They work on making sure their programs, teaching, campus, and support stay up to date and effective. They also inspire more global competition and offer chances to learn multiple languages.
Colleges need to be ready to change how they do things for the better, focusing on fairness, creativity, and excellence. They want to make college more accessible, help more students finish, and be fairer to everyone through inclusive policies. Creating a learning-focused culture helps schools tackle new challenges, find new chances, and keep being excellent.
“The ultimate goal of higher education should be to prepare individuals for fulfilling lives, not just successful careers. This requires a shift in mindset, away from the rankocracy that reinforces wealth and privilege, and towards empowering learners to make informed decisions about their education based on personal preferences and life prospects.”30
Investing in being the best in higher education is a big task. It calls for careful planning, new money ideas, and a constant push to be better. By filling every action with purpose, encouraging an atmosphere of excellence, and helping students choose wisely, schools can aim for the top in education, boost student success, and help society in many ways.
Conclusion
The strategic planning process led by the American Association of Colleges and Universities (AAC&U) has changed how we view higher education31. It showed us that despite tough challenges, like the COVID-19 pandemic, there are chances to make things better. Institutions are now more than ever encouraged to push for fairness, new ideas, and the best learning experience possible31.
Four goals in the AAC&U’s plan offer a path for bettering education. It aims to lead the way in a different kind of higher education, one that values change, fairness, and liberal education’s power31. This roadmap highlights the importance of turning institutions around, making things fairer, and focusing on how liberal education can change lives32.
Following this plan and working to grow a culture of fresh ideas will put your institution ahead in higher education. This will lead to a better educational journey for all students33. Your commitment to these ideas can influence the future of higher education. It will keep your institution shining as a place known for its quality, chances, and life-changing education32.
FAQ
What are the key components of academic quality?
How can institutional performance be measured?
What student behaviors and experiences contribute to success?
How can a supportive campus environment contribute to student success?
How has the COVID-19 pandemic impacted higher education?
How can faculty expertise and innovative teaching contribute to student success?
What strategies can help build a global reputation for higher education excellence?
How can higher education institutions prepare students for successful careers?
Why is embracing diversity and inclusion important for higher education excellence?
How can the campus experience beyond academics contribute to student learning and development?
What is the importance of interdisciplinary learning in higher education?
How can higher education institutions invest in resources to advance their mission?
Source Links
- https://educationise.com/post/unleashing-excellence-6-secrets-of-high-performing-students/ – Unleashing Excellence: 6 Secrets of High-Performing Students – Educationise
- https://www.cmu.edu/tepper/the-intelligent-future/strategic-plan/education-excellence.html – Education Excellence – Tepper School of Business – Carnegie Mellon University
- https://oirap.rutgers.edu/msa/documents/eheguide5-29.pdf – PDF
- https://www.enqa.eu/wp-content/uploads/ENQA-Excellence-WG-Report_The-Concept-of-Excellence-in-Higher-Education.pdf – PDF
- https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED524348.pdf – PDF
- https://www.quadc.io/blog/student-success-and-student-well-being-whats-the-connection – Student Success and Student Well-being: What’s the Connection?
- https://nces.ed.gov/npec/pdf/kuh_team_report.pdf – What Matters to Student Success: A Review of the Literature
- https://www.fisk.edu/ – Fisk University – The Cornerstone of Excellence and Education
- http://oirap.rutgers.edu/msa/documents/eheguide5-29.pdf – PDF
- https://www.ed.gov/raisethebar/college-excellence-equity – Raise the Bar: College Excellence and Equity
- https://www.forbes.com/sites/petermcpherson/2022/10/19/advancing-equity-in-higher-education-to-achieve-excellence/ – Advancing Equity In Higher Education To Achieve Excellence
- https://www.academicleadershipgroup.com/blog/leading-the-way-academic-leaders-and-a-culture-of-innovation – Leading the Way: Academic Leaders and a Culture of Innovation — Academic Leadership Group | Consulting for Higher Education
- https://www.hypeinnovation.com/blog/driving-innovation-higher-education-insights-from-lse-report – How to Drive Innovation in Higher Education to Stay Relevant and Sustainable
- https://www.aacu.org/strategic-plan – Equity, Innovation, and Excellence | AAC&U
- https://www.insightintodiversity.com/about-the-heed-award/past-recipients/ – Past HEED Recipients
- https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED524362.pdf – PDF
- https://www.pearson.com/en-us/higher-education/about-us/excellence-in-higher-education-awards.html – Recognize HE faculty meeting today’s challenges #HigherEducation #FacultyRecognition #OutstandingTeaching
- https://www.bcg.com/publications/2023/ten-lessons-for-universities-prepare-students-future-of-work – Ten Lessons for Universities to Prepare Students for Long-Term Success
- https://digitalcommons.nl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1351&context=diss – ADVOCATING FOR THE NEED OF A COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS PREPARATION ACCOUNTABLITY POLICY
- https://carolinanext.unc.edu/initiatives/career-development/ – Enable Career Development – Carolina Next
- https://operations.du.edu/sites/default/files/2020-04/model-of-inclusive-excellence.pdf – Toward a Model of Inclusive Excellence and Change in Postsecondary Institutions
- https://www.uwp.edu/explore/offices/EDI/upload/Making-Inclusive-Excellence.pdf – PDF
- https://diversity.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/berkeley_catalystsforchange_web_0.pdf – PDF
- https://www.teachforamerica.org/stories/education-beyond-academics – Education Beyond Academics | Teach For America
- https://medium.com/@utkarsh.gupta0311/maximizing-your-college-experience-beyond-academics-998790edacb6 – Maximizing Your College Experience: Beyond Academics
- https://education.gov.scot/media/bdahf0lv/idl-ambitious-learning-for-an-increasingly-complex-world-oct23.pdf – Interdisciplinary Learning: ambitious learning for an increasingly complex world – Updated October 2023
- https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ800366.pdf – http://jrp.icaap.org/index.php/jrp/rt/printerFriendly/104/101
- https://www.thebritishacademy.ac.uk/documents/213/crossing-paths.pdf – PDF
- https://www.ed.gov/raisethebar/ – Raise the Bar: Lead the World
- https://www.harvardmagazine.com/node/80173 – Aiming for Excellence | Harvard Magazine
- https://goglobal.fiu.edu/_assets/docs/doscher–landorf-2018_universal-global-learning,-inclusive-excellence,-and-higher-educations-greater-purpose.pdf – PDF
- https://christianscholars.com/identity-excellence-a-theory-of-moral-expertise-for-higher-education/ – Identity Excellence: A Theory of Moral Expertise for Higher Education – Christian Scholar’s Review
- https://www.nokut.no/siteassets/sfu/developing-educational-excellence-in-higher-education_2019.pdf – PDF